Product comparison

Scotch-Brite Sponge vs Compostable Kitchen Sponge

Standard kitchen sponges are replaced every 2-4 weeks and go straight to landfill. We compared scrubbing performance against a compostable alternative.

Our verdict

Winner: Compostable Kitchen Sponge

The compostable sponge matched Scotch-Brite on scrubbing performance in our test and, unlike petroleum-foam sponges, breaks down fully in a home compost bin instead of persisting in landfill and shedding microplastic fibers while in use.

Scotch-Brite Sponge

Scotch-Brite

$5.99 Eco 2.4/10

✓Effective scrubber
✓Cheap, widely available
✓Familiar texture

⭐ Winner

Compostable Kitchen Sponge

Twist

$8.99 Eco 8.5/10

✓100% compostable
✓Natural antibacterial

Feature comparison

Feature	Scotch-Brite Sponge	Compostable Kitchen Sponge
Price	$5.99 (9-pack)	$8.99 (comparable pack)
Material	Petroleum-based foam	Plant fiber, compostable
Scrubbing power	Strong	Strong
End of life	Landfill, sheds microplastic	Home compostable

Not sure which is right for you?

Take our quiz for a personalised recommendation based on your household and budget.

Take the free quiz →