Product comparison

Tide Pods vs Tru Earth Eco-Strips

Tide holds roughly a third of the US detergent market. Tru Earth swaps the plastic tub for a compostable strip. Here's how they actually compare.

Our verdict

Winner: Tru Earth Eco-Strips

Tru Earth matches Tide on everyday stains, ships in a fraction of the packaging weight, and costs less per load — the only edge Tide holds is on set-in heavy grease.

Tide Pods Original

Tide

$21.99 Eco 3.2/10

✓Excellent stain removal
✓Widely available
✓Trusted brand

⭐ Winner

Tru Earth Eco-Strips

Tru Earth

$14.99 Eco 9.4/10

✓Zero plastic
✓Works in cold water
✓Carbon neutral

Feature comparison

Feature	Tide Pods Original	Tru Earth Eco-Strips
Price per load	$0.35-$0.45	~$0.24
EWG grade	D-F (most formulas)	B
Packaging	Plastic tub	Cardboard sleeve
Cold water effective	Yes	Yes
Heavy grease stains	Best	Good

Not sure which is right for you?

Take our quiz for a personalised recommendation based on your household and budget.

Take the free quiz →